Custom Police Challenge Coins — Veteran & First Responder Owned, Long Island NY

When a police department orders a challenge coin, they're not just buying a piece of metal. They're commissioning something that will be carried through retirements, passed at promotions, and handed across a handshake at the end of a long shift. At HonestCoinsLI, we understand that — because we're part of that community.

Why Police Departments Choose HonestCoinsLI

We're a woman-owned, first responder and law enforcement-operated business based on Long Island, NY. Since 2015 we've made custom challenge coins for NYPD precincts, Nassau County PD, Suffolk County PD, and police departments across all 50 states. We donate a significant portion of our profits back to the first responder community — so when you order from us, you're supporting the brotherhood and sisterhood too.

All-Inclusive Pricing — No Surprises

Most companies advertise a low base price and then charge extra for 3D, additional colors, thick metal, two-sided detail, and custom textures. We don't. Our pricing is completely all-inclusive:

• 50 coins: $10.00 per coin (minimum order) • 100 coins: $7.75 per coin • Every order includes: free custom artwork, unlimited revisions, any size 1.75"–2.25", full 3D both sides, any plating, unlimited enamel colors, and free US shipping to all 50 states. • Digital proof delivered within 48 hours.

First Responder Discount Available

Active duty police officers receive a special discount with valid department ID. Contact us when requesting your quote to apply it.

What Goes on a Police Challenge Coin?

Every department is different, but the most meaningful police coins typically include:

• Department shield or badge replica — often the centerpiece, rendered in full 3D relief • Unit motto or department slogan — "To Protect and Serve," "Faithful Unto Death," or your own • Rank or division designation — Precinct number, unit name, special division • Founding year or anniversary date — especially popular for department milestones • Officer name or badge number — for retirement and commendation coins • Department seal or patch design — converted from your existing patch artwork • Thin Blue Line — a common design element honoring fallen officers

Popular Police Coin Types

• Retirement Coins — The most sentimental coin an officer will ever receive. Usually presented at the retirement ceremony and kept for life. • Promotion Coins — Given when an officer makes detective, sergeant, lieutenant, or captain. A physical marker of achievement. • Unit/Precinct Coins — Ordered in bulk for the whole squad. Used in the challenge tradition and as morale items. • Memorial Coins — Honoring a fallen officer. These are made with extra care and reverence. • Chief's Coins — The commanding officer's personal coin, used to recognize exceptional service.

Rush Orders Available

Have a retirement ceremony, promotion, or memorial event coming up fast? We offer rush production options. Standard production is 4–8 weeks — contact us with your deadline and we'll do everything we can to meet it.

Departments We've Served

We've made custom police challenge coins for departments across Long Island, New York City, and the nation — including NYPD, Nassau County Police Department, Suffolk County Police Department, and hundreds of local, county, and state police agencies. We serve departments of all sizes, from small-town departments ordering 50 coins to large agencies ordering 1,000+.

Ready to get started? Request your free quote at HonestCoinsLI.com. No obligation, no payment until you approve the design. Woman-owned. First responder community. Keeping the Tradition Alive since 2015.