Custom Fire Department Challenge Coins — Made for the Brotherhood

Firefighters live and work by a code — loyalty, sacrifice, and brotherhood that runs deeper than most people will ever know. A custom fire department challenge coin is one of the few physical objects that captures that spirit. At HonestCoinsLI, we've been making them for firehouses across Long Island and the country since 2015.

First Responder-Owned. We Get It.

HonestCoinsLI is a woman-owned business operated by first responders and law enforcement on Long Island, NY. We don't just make coins for the fire service — we're part of it. We've served FDNY firehouses, Long Island volunteer and career fire departments, and fire companies from coast to coast. A portion of every order goes back to the first responder community.

All-Inclusive Pricing — What You See Is What You Pay

• 50 coins: $10.00 per coin (minimum order) • 100 coins: $7.75 per coin • Included at no extra charge: free custom artwork & unlimited revisions, any size 1.75"–2.25", full 3D both sides, any plating finish, unlimited enamel colors, any edge style, free US shipping to all 50 states, digital proof within 48 hours. • First Responder Discount available with valid department ID.

What to Put on a Fire Department Coin

The best fire department coins tell the story of the house at a glance. Common design elements include:

• Company or department logo — helmet shield, Maltese cross, department patch replica • Company number and station — "Engine 5," "Ladder 3," "Station 22" • Department motto or code — "Semper Paratus," "Always Ready," or your house's own saying • Founding year or milestone anniversary • Rank insignia — especially for chief's coins and retirement coins • Red Line or thin red stripe — honoring fallen firefighters • Flames, ladder, axe, or Halligan — classic fire service iconography in 3D relief

Most Popular Fire Department Coin Orders

• Retirement Coins — The ultimate send-off for a firefighter hanging up their gear. Presented at the retirement party or final roll call, kept for a lifetime. • Promotional Coins — Marking the moment a firefighter makes lieutenant, captain, battalion chief, or chief of department. • Company Coins — Ordered in bulk for the whole house, used in the challenge tradition and as morale boosters. • Memorial Coins — The most solemn coin we make. Honoring a line-of-duty death with the reverence it deserves. • Fundraiser Coins — Sold or auctioned to raise money for families, equipment, or charitable causes.

Rush Orders Available

Retirement ceremony next month? Memorial service coming up? We offer rush production. Standard turnaround is 4–8 weeks — reach out with your date and we'll work to make it happen.

Volunteer and Career Departments Welcome

We serve both career and volunteer fire departments with the same quality and pricing. Whether you're a small volunteer company ordering 50 coins or a career department ordering 500, the all-inclusive price and free design service are the same.

Start your order with a free quote at HonestCoinsLI.com. No payment until you approve the design. Digital proof in 48 hours. Woman-owned. First responder community. Keeping the Tradition Alive since 2015.