Custom Challenge Coin

All-Inclusive Custom Challenge Coins — No Hidden Fees. Ever.
We're a veteran and first responder–owned small business on Long Island, NY. Every coin we make is built to honor the people who wear the badge — law enforcement, fire departments, military units, EMS crews, and the families that support them. When you order with us, you get a real human who answers the phone, cares about your order, and gives back to the community you serve.



💰 Transparent Pricing — No Surprises

  

    

      
Quantity
      
Price Per Coin
      
What's Included
    
  
  

    

      
50 coins
      
$10.00 / coin
      
Any size (1.75"–2.25"), any thickness, 3D both sides, any plating color, unlimited enamel colors, free design, free US shipping
    
    

      
100 coins
      
$7.75 / coin
    
  

Need a different quantity? Contact us for a custom quote. First responders receive an additional discount — just provide your department ID at checkout.



⏱ Turnaround Time

  
Standard production: 4–8 weeks
  
Digital proof: within 48 hours of placing your order
  
Rush orders: available — contact us to discuss your deadline
  
Shipping: Free standard US shipping included on all orders




🎨 What's Included in Every Order

  
✅ Any size: 1.75", 2.0", or 2.25" diameter
  
✅ Any thickness — standard or thick
  
✅ 3D relief design, both sides
  
✅ Any plating: gold, silver, antique gold/silver, black, copper, and more
  
✅ Unlimited enamel fill colors
  
✅ Free custom design by our in-house artist
  
✅ Digital proof for approval before production
  
✅ Free US shipping
  
✅ Individual poly bags included




🔧 How It Works — 5 Simple Steps

  
Order & Submit Details — Tell us your unit, department, rank, or theme. Upload any logos or artwork you have.
  
Free Design Proof — Our artist creates a custom digital proof within 48 hours. No charge, no obligation until you approve.
  
Approve Your Design — Review, request revisions (unlimited), and approve when you're 100% happy.
  
Production — Your coins are cast, plated, and finished by hand. Standard lead time is 4–8 weeks.
  
Free Shipping to Your Door — Coins are packaged in individual poly bags and shipped free anywhere in the US.




⭐ What Our Customers Say

  
"Ordered 100 coins for our unit and couldn't be more impressed. The detail on these is incredible — every officer was blown away. Fast communication and the price beat everyone else we quoted."
— Nassau County PD Unit


  
"We've ordered challenge coins from several vendors over the years. HonestCoinsLI is the only one we'll go back to. Transparent pricing, real people, and coins that make us proud."
— Long Island Fire Department

We hold a perfect 5.0 Google rating and are DUNS registered and AAA certified. We donate a significant portion of profits back to the first responder community.



🏅 Popular Coin Types

  
Police Challenge Coins — PBA coins, unit awards, retirement coins, K-9 coins
  
Fire Department Challenge Coins — Station commemoratives, retirement, brotherhood coins
  
Military Challenge Coins — Unit coins, deployment coins, veterans coins, rank coins
  
EMS & First Responder Coins — Paramedic, EMT, dispatch appreciation coins
  
Corporate & Organization Coins — Employee awards, anniversary coins, charity fundraisers




📞 Ready to Order?
Call or text us at (516) 315-9568 · Email: info@HonestCoinsLI.com
We serve Long Island, New York City, and ship free nationwide. NYPD, FDNY, Nassau County PD, Suffolk County PD, and hundreds of military units trust us with their most meaningful recognition pieces.