How Much Do Custom Challenge Coins Cost? HonestCoinsLI Pricing Breakdown

If you've ever tried to get a quote for custom challenge coins, you've probably run into the same frustrating experience: vague pricing, surprise add-ons, and fees for things you assumed were standard. Mold fees. Setup charges. Extra costs for more than two colors. It adds up fast — and makes it hard to budget.

At HonestCoinsLI, we do things differently. Our pricing is straightforward, all-inclusive, and honest — no hidden fees, no upsells, no surprises. Based right here on Long Island, NY, we're a veteran and first responder owned business, and we built our pricing the way we wish every vendor operated: clearly and fairly.

HonestCoinsLI Pricing — Simple and All-Inclusive

Here's exactly what you'll pay for custom challenge coins from HonestCoinsLI:

• 50 coins — $10.00 each ($500 total)

• 100 coins — $7.75 each ($775 total)

That's it. No tiers for "premium" plating. No extra charge for 3D design. No fee for unlimited colors. What you see above is what you pay — everything included.

What's Included in Every Order

When we say all-inclusive, we mean it. Here's everything that comes with your order at no additional cost:

• Any size from 1.75" to 2.25"

• Any thickness from 1mm to 4mm

• 3D design on both sides

• Any plating finish — gold, silver, antique, black nickel, dual plating, and more

• Unlimited colors

• Free artwork and custom design

• Free unlimited revisions until you're happy

• Free US shipping — no minimums

• No mold fees

• No setup fees

• No hidden charges — ever

Why Other Companies Charge More (And What They're Really Charging For)

Most challenge coin vendors advertise a low per-coin price — sometimes as low as $3 or $4 each. But by the time you add in the mold fee ($50–$200), setup charge, artwork fee, per-color charge, and shipping, you're often paying the same or more than our flat rate. The difference is we tell you the real number upfront.

We built HonestCoinsLI specifically because, as veterans and first responders ourselves, we were tired of vendors nickel-and-diming the people who serve. Police departments, fire houses, military units, and veterans organizations shouldn't have to budget-engineer a challenge coin order. You should know what it costs before you commit.

Who Orders From HonestCoinsLI?

We serve customers across Long Island and nationwide. Our clients include:

• Police departments and law enforcement agencies

• Fire departments and EMS units

• Active duty military and veteran organizations

• Corporate teams, clubs, and fraternal organizations

Whether you're commissioning coins to recognize a retirement, commemorate a deployment, celebrate a department milestone, or represent your brand — the process is the same: you get a real price, a real design, and a real person to work with.

How the Process Works

Ordering custom challenge coins from HonestCoinsLI is simple:

1. Submit a free quote request — tell us your quantity, size preference, and any design ideas you have.

2. We send a digital proof — our designers create your artwork for free, usually within 1–2 business days.

3. You review and revise — as many times as needed, completely free.

4. Approve and order — once you're happy, we go to production.

5. Coins ship free to your door — anywhere in the US.

There's no obligation to buy at any stage before you approve the final design and place your order. The quote is free. The artwork is free. If you decide it's not right for you, you owe us nothing.

The Bottom Line

50 coins for $500. 100 coins for $775. Everything included — design, plating, colors, revisions, and shipping. No surprises when the invoice arrives.

At HonestCoinsLI — Veteran & First Responder Owned, serving Long Island and beyond — we believe the people who serve deserve vendors they can trust. That starts with honest pricing.

Ready to see what your coins could look like? Get your free quote — no obligation to buy.