Custom Firefighter Challenge Coins — Made by the Brotherhood, For the Brotherhood

Firefighters put everything on the line every single shift. At Honest Coins LI — a family-run, veteran and first-responder-owned company based on Long Island, NY — we believe the coins carried by the fire service should be made by people who understand exactly what that service means. We've been creating custom firefighter challenge coins since 2015, and we're proud to serve fire companies, departments, and fire chiefs across the country.

Why Fire Companies Trust Honest Coins LI

• First Responder Owned & Operated — Our team includes active firefighters and EMS personnel. We speak your language and respect your traditions.

• All-Inclusive Pricing — Any size (1.75" to 2.25"), any thickness (1mm to 4mm), 3D on both sides, any plating, unlimited colors. One price, no surprises.

• Free Artwork & Unlimited Revisions — Send us your Maltese cross, helmet, or department logo. We'll design a proof you'll be proud to carry.

• Fast Production — Proof in ~48 hours, coins in ~14 business days. Perfect for retirement ceremonies, promotions, and annual dinners.

• Free US Shipping — To your firehouse, your station, or your door. Every time.

• We Give Back — We donate a significant portion of profits back to the first responder community. When you order from us, you're supporting the brotherhood.

How to Order Custom Fire Department Challenge Coins

1. Request Your Free Quote — Tell us your department name, design ideas, quantity, and any special details like engine number or LODD memorial.

2. Approve Your Proof — We'll send a detailed 3D design proof within about 48 hours. Make changes until it's exactly right — at no charge.

3. Receive Your Coins — ~14 business days to production. Free delivery anywhere in the US.

Pricing — Everything Included

50 coins: $10.00 each | 100 coins: $7.00 each

Includes: any size 1.75"–2.25", any thickness 1mm–4mm, 3D both sides, any plating, unlimited colors, free artwork, free revisions, free US shipping. No die charges, no hidden fees.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I put a Maltese cross or fire helmet on my coin?

Absolutely. Maltese crosses, helmets, axes, ladders, engine numbers — our designers specialize in fire service imagery and will make your coin look outstanding.

Do you make LODD memorial coins?

Yes. We handle memorial coin orders with the utmost care and respect. Please reach out directly so we can give your order the attention it deserves.

What's the minimum order?

Our minimum order is 50 coins. This covers departments of all sizes, from small volunteer fire companies to large municipal departments.

Can I order coins for a retirement or promotion ceremony?

Yes — retirement, promotion, and annual dinner coins are some of our most popular. We can personalize each coin with rank, years of service, badge number, and a custom message.

How quickly can you turn around an order?

Standard production is approximately 14 business days after design approval. Contact us if you have a hard deadline and we'll do everything we can to meet it.

Start Your Order Today

Your fire company deserves coins made by people who get it. Request your free quote at HonestCoinsLI.com — free artwork, free revisions, free shipping, and a team that's been in the brotherhood their whole lives.